Tag Archive | "The Supremes"

Early album influences made Carlos Alomar a complete musician


By Carol Anne Szel

To merely call Carlos Alomar a guitarist is a gross understatement. With thirty two international Platinum and Gold records to his name playing with artists from David Bowie to James Brown, John Lennon and Paul McCartney to Iggy Pop, and a veritable potpourri of musical icons in between, this R&B/Punk/Pop/Rock musical legend is still a driving force today at age 60.

While his discography page looking more like the trophy wall of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame then a web site, this Puerto Rican born/Bronx raised artist continues to remain a mainstay in contemporary music. Working recently with the likes of Alicia Keys and Jennifer Hudson, Alomar has also taken on residency as the Distinguished Artist in Residence at Stevens Institute of Technology.

Discussing the past, present, and future of music and it’s ever changing chronicles, I had the honor and privilege to sit down and talk with Carlos Alomar recently as we learn of what albums influenced his musical and personal life.

 

Carlos Alomar: First of all, the issue of taking ten albums is extremely difficult. The issue of having to decide what [has] influenced as opposed to what did you influence. You know what I mean? These components really create this terrible confusion in my brain as to what albums did influence me. And where was it apparent that this influence came to light? You know, to be influenced by something, its like “My Sweet Lord.” Finally you’re playing this song and you never realize you’ve been influenced. You don’t even know the history, but somewhere along the line you’ve heard something and it just popped up.

Also, another factor is, I love certain songs. But it isn’t the song that you’re asking me for, it is the albums that you’re asking me for. And so that creates another sort of complication. It was difficult in that I had to actually put a million songs down and then starting to analyze it in a form of like ‘what influenced my technique’ because I have to acknowledge that. And what influenced my sensibilities. So those two criteria were the ones I used for the choices I made.

Now there are some inherit problems found in this in that sometimes the influences that I felt were when I was younger, and now that I’m approaching 60 it becomes difficult to see what influenced me recently. So I had to look at it and I realized that most of my influences started early, early on. So I have to start there.

I’m going to start with “Revolver” by the Beatles. Now it’s very difficult to speak about the Beatles because to me they were [it], ten years from the ’60s to maybe the ’70s. So basically…all of the Beatles albums as one influence, but “Revolver” was by far the one that made me leaving that nice, nice area they were in. Going into the more psychedelic, and just all of them having an influence. Harrison stepping out more as a guitarist and writing. That album for me was landmark.

Then a friend of mine introduced me to Jimi Hendrix “Are You Experienced.” As a guitarist I went crazy. First of all, it was coupled with the advent of the stereophonic, hi-fi system. Remember, even with some of the Beatles and some of those other tracks, we had kind of the pseudo-mono. It hadn’t really evolved the way it should have. So Jimi Hendrix came out and it was so influential as a guitarist. I’d like to put it this way, during that same ’60s period that I noted to you — with not only the Beatles but you had Herman’s Hermits — you had all these other bands that were playing at that time and I had just gotten influenced by them. But the guitarist wasn’t the main force. He was interesting as some component and every once in a while a guitarist would step out to play a little lead. But the issue of a power trio was unheard of. And when he [Hendrix] stepped in front with a Marshall and a Strat, I couldn’t believe it. First of all I had to listen to the record a few times when I first heard it with the friend that said ‘what’s wrong with you?’ And then I bought the record and that was it, the record got scratched up immediately because I had to learn every note. And I did, I learned that whole album!

I was influenced, too, by the San Francisco Bay area in the early ’60s or late ’60s actually. There was a band called Cold Blood. And remember, we’re going from the psychedelic kind of thing, and now we’re looking at kind of the R&B fuse kind of thing of rock and blues and jazz. They had this amazing horn section with a singer Lydia Pense that was like Janis Joplin. Rough and hard, singing blues and singing hardcore. The horn section rivaled Blood Sweat & Tears, Chicago … They were like ridiculously awesome. As a group, as a band, they were fronted by a horn section. When I heard Cold Blood, they were the ones who made it for me.

Also, the big one. James Brown. And for me, his particular album was “Say it Loud, I’m Black and I’m Proud.” Now that was influential to me in a different way. Obviously because of the funk factor. But for me if was mostly influential on a different esoteric because as a Latino man, they did not teach Latin American history at that time. It was 1969, you know, late ’60s. I was 18 years old and the whole issue of pride came up at that point. And so not understanding my own history, I finally find out that the Puerto Rican is actually a combination of the Taino Indian, the African slaves, and the Spaniards. So the consciousness of that song, “I’m Black and I’m Proud” really created a moment in my life where black music was a little bit harder felt for me. Just for the sake of the fact that it had its own identity now. That music influenced me as a character, as a personality, as a person.

The next year, 1970, Santana came out with the album “Abraxas.” Now Santana, being a Latino, once again we’re going toward that influence. Now, I see this Latin, for the first time, a Latin guitar player being fronted by any singer he wanted. And from that album you have “Black Magic Woman.” Oh my God, that album was crazy, that album was amazing. “Black Magic Woman,” “Oye Como Va,” “Incident at Neshabur,” all these songs were really heavy duty.

I’d have to include Django Reinhardt. Now the album is called “Django Reinhardt and the Hot Club Quintet.” This man had an accident in his mid-life where he was in a fire and two of his fingers on his right hand were burned and fused together. Now you’re looking at a man who has a thumb and two fingers on his right hand, what we call his ‘picking hand.’ This man developed a technique for gypsy guitar that is the fastest guitar — forget shredding, forget flamenco, forget all of that. This Jazz guitar player is the most amazing guitar player that I have ever heard in my life. He developed his own technique. Guitar gymnastics that will make a million guitar players stop playing guitar for the rest of their lives.

The Main Ingredient “Afrodisiac” album. That has a different type of explanation. I joined the Main Ingredient and that was the first album that I performed on, and that was because I was a session artist for RCA. So it was the place where I finally got the chance to show the world what I had. In particular, there is a song on that album called “You Can Call Me Rover” which if you listen to it you’ll hear little bits of what would later become (David Bowie’s) “Fame.” So that one has to be noted because that kind of took my whole R&B history and at that point it kind of came to an end — not to an end, but there was a period where that stopped and I joined Bowie and obviously slipped into the rock and roll epoch of my life.

Now I have to list David Bowie of course. And the one I’d have to pick is “Young Americans.” And the reason is, I never really had much confidence in the blue-eyed soul situation. Wait, before that I have to mention another influence.

There were some things that happened when I met Bowie. One of the influences that he introduced me to was a band called Kraftwerk. Kraftwerk was a German instrumental band, and they had an album called “Trans-Europe Express.” And that album for me was influential in that it introduced me to this, for lack of a better term, new-age music. Not psychedelic, but that trance-like melodic theme you get not only in disco music but they also gave me a glimpse early on into the whole, what we call, soundscapes. Yes it is instrumental music, but it isn’t instrumental music like for movies. It had a type of beat to it and it had the pounding kick drum, and, of course, songs that go on for like eight minutes.

Kraftwerk was a major, major influence to me; to allow me to take my mindset away from R&B and away from Rock and Roll and kind of couple it with classical music. It allowed me to understand the development of a song. Because usually in pop music and in different cultures we have to get to it right away. Verse chorus, verse chorus, bridge, out. And yet in classical music, you introduce the scene with anything, there’s a prologue to everything. That was about 1975, 76.

Some of these albums are the fact is it’s an influential albums. But then I have to give commentary about how. And the obvious was David Bowie’s “Trilogy” with Brian Eno that I was a part of. All of that happened around this same time. It’s linear, it’s not verse chorus, verse chorus. You know the verse could be the whole song.

Now remember there was a big conflict in 1977, iIn the ’70s, let’s call it, with disco music. Disco music had a different impact than people think. Let’s understand time of a record. In the pop culture of the ’60s, songs were less than three minutes long. As they approached the ’70s, as they left the ’70s, they started becoming longer and longer and longer, where we had disco music in that period of the late ’70s/early ’80s — these songs, oh my god, six minutes long was not out of the question.

And then the artist found out a little known truth. If your record is longer than four minutes long, you get paid for two songs. So you know what? Everyone had songs that were like six minutes long! Yeah, you got more for the longer songs. They soon stopped that practice, but other than that it was a great influence at that time.

Another influential album for me, although I played on it, I have to acknowledge it. It was “Lust for Life“by Iggy Pop. At the same time in 1977 I was introduced to Iggy Pop by David Bowie. And the difference in that influence was that it changed my sensibility in my performance and to revisit punk music as a driving force of what made me feel good and what I needed in order to be a guitarist.

The influence of the pop culture in the ’60s and the rock and roll culture in the ’70s created this nuance that gave me a more sophisticated, not only technique, but my own feeling of comfort. The minute I joined Iggy Pop in his albums, and then later on touring, that whole sensibility took a big change. As there is no back line in punk music, everybody is in the front line with the singer. I wasn’t looking at myself as a rhythm guitar player anymore, now I was a lead guitar player that will kick you in your face if he feels like it! So Iggy gave me a force that I would take into my later life.

The Supremes had a greatest hits album that I used to listen to with my wife Robin. It was “The Best of the Supremes,” and of course it had “Baby Love,” “Where Did Your Love Go,” “Stone Love,” “Reflections.” As you can see, none of the albums I listed are girl trios or girl singers in particular. But there was something about that music. When I was very, very young I heard “Baby Love” through a rolled-down car window. And that influenced me so much. I was a minister’s son and so I was only allowed to play church music. So for me to hear R&B music: The Supremes, The Temptations, I was like ‘oh my god, what are those chords? ‘Oh my god, what are those progressions?’ ‘Oh my god, how amazing!’ They had a bridge, I never knew what a bridge was. A bridge by definition is a totally different song that you just take and put inside of a song. But the reason is, when you think of a song, usually the highlight of a song is the chorus. Now when you think the song can not get any higher, when you think it can’t get any better than it is, you take it to the bridge and that other song kicks in there for about two seconds, your brain just explodes and then you go into super overdrive!

James Brown would take it to the bridge, and [once] I got fined. I was in working with his band as a pick-up musician and I didn’t hit when he said ‘take it to the bridge’ and they docked me fifty dollars. Oh, it’s a serious business if you don’t hit the bridge when it comes around. He wasn’t tough to work with, he was James Brown. He was a task master. And, true to word, he could pick up in the very next stop. Anybody was dying to play with James Brown, so for me to play with James Brown was like ‘oh my god.”

James Brown, Wilson Pickett, Chuck Berry. And these were all people that I performed with or toured with or worked with in the ’60s and yet they were so part of my culture that the influence wasn’t crazy, crazy. It was just there.

So it becomes very difficult when you have to think about what influenced you. Because you have to come from a place that you already were. And influence means to be taken from where you are and influenced to go somewhere else.

Oh wait, I have to put one more band in there. Sly and the Family Stone were the first interracial band to perform at the Apollo Theater. And this was I guess ’68, myself, my wife, and my best friend Luther Vandross were at a small workshop at the basement of the Apollo Theater. We were part of a workshop called “Listen My Brother.” We rehearsed, rehearsed, and rehearsed and our big thing was that we were going to be the opening act for Sly and the Family Stone, in the Apollo Theater, to open up. When we entered into that world, Sly and the Family Stone changed us very quickly. Remember, we were going from the R&B, classic R&B rhythm session/band where you’re sitting down, you are in a sense a band. You don’t stand up, only the lead singer gets in front of the microphone. Suddenly, Sly and the Family Stone comes to the Apollo Theater and the back line gets Fender amplifiers from the floor over three or four stories high to the top of the curtain. From the stage, all you saw was the gray material of the amplifiers. They destroyed that theater so bad it was never the same! And they destroyed me as well!

When we went backstage and to the hotel with them, that was it. I had just finished coming from the chitlin’ circuit of R&B music where the managers would have to take their guns and get their guns ready while everybody waited by the bus when they had to go in to get their money. Where you would take the bus and the bus would stop somewhere in the woods and there would be this speakeasy or whatever it would be called. You’re coming from that into the light of rock and roll, come on. I was like ‘oh my god, I want to do this.’

And a few years later when I had the chance to meet Bowie, that was it. I left R&B and never looked back.

Related Posts:

Posted in 10 Albums, FeaturesComments (0)

Mary, Miracles, Marvelettes – Motown’s missing from Rock Hall


This album, from 1962, shows a different picture of Motown Records than is remembered today, with The Miracles, Mary Wells & The Marvelettes getting top billing at the Apollo over Marv (!) Gaye, The Contours, Stevie Wonder & The Supremes

By Phill Marder

(13th in a series on artists who should be in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, but are not)

Motown Records became known as “The Sound of Young America.” Its sister label, Tamla, was “The Sound that Makes the World Go ‘Round.”

There was little dispute in the 60s, and I would suspect no more today, that Motown/Tamla was one of the dominant, if not the most dominant, forces in Rock & Roll. Certainly, the Detroit powerhouse is well represented in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, as it should be. Maybe not as much as another label which shall remain nameless (couldn’t resist…sorry). But well represented, nonetheless.

However, three cornerstones of perhaps the most famous label in Rock & Roll have yet to be included, though their credentials dwarf many of those already inducted.

The first is Mary Wells, who was on my list in Goldmine (please see the introduction to this blog if you haven’t already) closing in on 11 years ago now. My assumption is that one day Mary Wells will be an inductee. Unfortunately, she won’t be around to enjoy the accolades, having passed away from throat cancer in 1992.

Mary Wells

Wells practically carried Motown on her back when the label was struggling to get a foothold in the industry. She became known as “The Queen of Motown” but her bitter split with the label killed her career at its peak. Just 17, she brought a song she had written for Jackie Wilson to Tamla Records founder Berry Gordy Jr. Gordy’s main source of income at the time came from several hits he had co-written for Wilson, including “To Be Loved,” “Reet Petite” and the mega smash “Lonely Teardrops.”

The teenager sang “Bye Bye Baby” for Gordy, who signed her and had her do the song herself. It became a hit and Wells was on her way. Her follow-up, “I Don’t Want To Take A Chance,” was a tad more successful, but after Wells’ third effort tanked Gordy made a decision that soon made Wells a superstar. He told Smokey Robinson to write her some hits.

Wells had a Bonnie Tyler-roughness to her voice on her first two efforts, but Robinson smoothed her out on their first collaboration and the result was “The One Who Really Loves You,” which climbed to No. 8. The classic “You Beat Me To The Punch” followed, hitting No. 9 and Wells, Motown and Gordy were well on their way. Another collaboration – “Two Lovers” eclipsed the previous two smashes, climbing to No. 7 and the magnificent “Laughing Boy” made it to No. 15.

After “Your Old Stand By” stalled at No. 40, the relatively new team of Brian Holland, Lamont Dozier and Eddie Holland Jr. took a shot and the result was the No. 22 “You Lost The Sweetest Boy.” Ironically, the flip, “What’s Easy For Two Is So Hard For One,” written and produced by Robinson, trailed, though it settled at a very successful No. 29.

Perhaps challenged by the new upstarts, Robinson responded with one of his greatest works, “My Guy,” which soared to No. 1 and became an all-time classic.

Former Motown sales chief Barney Ales was quoted as saying, “In 1964 Mary Wells was our big, big artist. I don’t think there’s an audience with an age of 30 through 50 that doesn’t know the words to ‘My Guy.’”

Wells was the big, big artist on the label that boasted the Miracles, the Temptations, the Supremes, Stevie Wonder, Marvin Gaye and many other household names. Of course, 1964 was also the year of The British Invasion. The Beatles reportedly named Wells their favorite singer and she traveled to Britain to open for the group, becoming the first Motown star to appear in the United Kingdom. Her impact was immediate. “My Guy” became Motown’s first UK smash, reaching No. 5, preceding the Supremes’ “Where Did Our Love Go” by several months and opening the door for a flood of Motown smashes that followed and never relented.

“My Guy” also was the Motown label’s first No. 1 record in the United States, again beating “Where Did Our Love Go” by a couple months. Previous Motown chart-toppers by the Marvelettes and Stevie Wonder had been on the Tamla label. It also came in the midst of the Beatles’ initial onslaught on the states, when the British invaders posted four No. 1 records between February and June.

She added two more top 20 hits in 1964, both being duets with Gaye pulled from their “Together” album, but 1964 also marked the end of her career as a hit maker. Reportedly unhappy with her circumstances at Motown, she left the label for 20th Century, virtually disappearing overnight. The backlash created by her departing Motown may have torpedoed her career, but more than anything was the absence of classic material the Motown songwriters, especially Robinson, could provide. The greatest singer in the world won’t find a hit without the proper material.

Still, there’s no questioning the impact Mary Wells had on Rock & Roll and the eventual success of the Motown label and its subsidiaries. She might not be here physically, but her music lives on and her memory should be cherished and preserved by The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

The Miracles

The second omission is one of the most confounding by an organization that seems to specialize in goofy decisions. How did Smokey Robinson get inducted without the Miracles?

Robinson certainly deserves solo induction due to his songwriting, producing, solo career and his contributions in many official capacities in Motown’s front office. But if the Supremes got in with Diana Ross and the Vandellas made it in with Martha Reeves and the three other Tops made it in with Levi Stubbs, how could the Miracles, who were much more important, not get in with Smokey?

The 1987 gaffe created quite a ruckus then, but, evidently, not enough to get the injustice righted. Read Robinson’s biography on the official Hall of Fame site and the Miracles are present from start to finish. But check the list of inductees and they’re still absent, both under Miracles and individual names.

While the Temptations set the bar for vocal variety and choreography, the Miracles did their part in backing Smokey on stage, certainly with more flair than the Supremes, Vandellas or Tops. If you weren’t around during their heyday, grab a copy of the T.A.M.I. show and check out “Mickey’s Monkey.”

The members who weren’t Smokey – Ronnie White, Bobby Rogers, Pete Moore and Claudette Robinson – also played an important part in other facets of the Miracles’ success. While Robinson is credited as being one of the greatest of Rock’s songsmiths, he did have help. White, a childhood friend who recorded some duets with Smokey before the Miracles were formed, was listed as co-writer of such gems as “Don’t Look Back,” “You Beat Me To The Punch,” “Ain’t That Peculiar” and the all-time classic “My Girl.” He also is credited with discovering Stevie Wonder, then his 11-year-old neighbor.

Rogers was born in the same hospital as Robinson on the same day, but they didn’t meet until they were teenagers. Rogers and Claudette Robinson were cousins. Rogers also is an accomplished songwriter. Among his Motown writing credits are “The Way You Do The Things You Do,” “My Baby,” “What Love Has Joined Together,” “First I Look At The Purse,” “One More Heartache,” That’s What Love Is Made Of” and “Going To A Go-Go.”

Rogers also is the most important prominent co-lead vocal on the classic “You Really Got A Hold Me.”

Warren “Pete” Moore was also a childhood friend of Robinson’s and a founding member of the Miracles. Besides singing lead on the hit “Doggone Right,” Moore was the group’s vocal arranger and also a prolific writer. His credits include “It’s Growing,” “Since I Lost My Baby,” “Ain’t That Peculiar, “I’ll Be Doggone,” “Ooo Baby Baby,” “The Tracks Of My Tears,” “Going To A Go-Go,” and “Love Machine,” a No. 1 hit for the Miracles in 1975, long after Robinson left the group.

Claudette Robinson took the place of her drafted brother, Emerson, when the Miracles were born and married Smokey, the pairing lasting 27 years. She didn’t make many stage appearances, but sang with the Miracles in the studio until Smokey left the group. The first female contracted by the Motown empire, she was dubbed “The First Lady Of Motown” by Berry Gordy Jr.

From 1959 until 1966, the Miracles were known as just that…The Miracles. They were one of the most popular groups in the world. After the Robinsons departed, the Miracles continued having success, including scoring the above-mentioned No. 1 single.

I defy you to name the Vandellas. But they’re in the Hall of Fame as Martha & the Vandellas. Likewise, the Four Tops. Some could probably name Mary Wilson, Florence Ballard or Cindy Birdsong as Supremes, but, in reality, their role was just to provide backup for Diana Ross. Except for Claudette, though, the Miracles all played a vital role in the group’s success from its outset. So why are they left out while the others are in?

Frankly, Smokey Robinson proved a disappointment. There’s no question he deserves induction, but he should have refused unless his group was included.

The Marvelettes

The third missing Motown link is the marvelous Marvelettes, overshadowed by the Supremes but still worthy of Hall of Fame recognition.

Who had the first No. 1 record on the Motown/Tamla label? It makes a great party trivia question, and few are likely to get the correct answer. After all, when you have The Miracles, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes, Mary Wells, Marvin Gaye and others to choose from, the group that did it – the Marvelettes – is often forgotten. As they have been by the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

The above-mentioned gem was “Please Mr. Postman,” the group’s first single later covered by the Beatles. Starting at the top, there was no place for the Marvelettes to go but down, which they did. But not without a fight.

The group had a rare feature with two lead singers, Gladys Horton and Wanda Young, who later married the Miracles’ Bobby Rogers. This abundance of talent helped the Marvelettes make marvelous music, but may have hurt the group as the public had no star to focus on ala Diana Ross or Martha Reeves. Georgeanna Tillman, Katharine Anderson and Juanita Cowart rounded out the original lineup.

The year following “Please Mr. Postman,” 1962 for those who enjoy some facts in their reading materials, the Marvelettes hit the Top 10 again with “Playboy” and followed with “Beechwood 4-5789,” my personal favorite that inexplicably, to me at least, stopped at No. 17. “Someday, Someway,” a terrific song, was buried on the flipside.

Another disappointment was “Strange I Know,” one of the group’s finest efforts which closed the year peaking at No. 49, a flop by Motown standards even in those early years. Cowart left in 1962 and 1963 was a barren year, though “As Long As I Know He’s Mine” was a strong effort popular in some circles. In 1964, the group made what, in retrospect, appears to be a history changing decision. They turned down “Where Did Our Love Go,” which then became the Supremes’ first No. 1. The group continued to flounder until “Too Many Fish In The Sea” (couldn’t resist…sorry) got them back on track – if only temporarily – as 1964 wound down.

The biggest news for the group in 1965 was Gordon’s departure. But the next two years saw the Marvelettes release three singles that became classics – “Don’t Mess With Bill,” which returned the group to the Top 10, and “The Hunter Gets Captured By The Game” and “My Baby Must Be A Magician,” both of which earned top 20 status.

The Marvelettes gave us eight years of terrific records, including Motown’s first chart-topper. Their credentials for Hall of Fame status may not match those of many of their stablemates, but they match or exceed many of those already inducted by the Hall of Fame.

Related Posts:

Posted in Blogs, Great Blogs Of FireComments (26)

Motown at 50: Funky Motown! part 2


By  Dave Thompson

Stevie Wonder was one of the artists who helped establish Motown as a force to be reckoned within the music world. (Motown)

Stevie Wonder was one of the artists who helped establish Motown as a force to be reckoned within the music world. (Motown)
Inspired by both the emergent rock-funk fusion sounds of Sly & The Family Stone and the socially aware songs of Motown’s latest writing team, the Clan (R. Dean Taylor, Pam Sawyer, Frank Wilson and Deke Richards, authors of The Supremes’ “Love Child”), Whitfield and partner Barrett Strong commenced their assault on Motown’s ingrained sensibilities with “Cloud Nine,” a psychedelic-soul synthesis which combined momentum and message to emerge utterly unique.

With The Temptations set to record the song, Babbitt, Jones, Coffey and Ragin were all present for the session, the first named to lay down the pulsing beat which drove the song inexorably on, the latter to layer the rock-inflected guitars which Whitfield required.

According to drummer Jones, interviewed by author Nelson George, Whitfield “ … came into the studio one day and said ‘I wanna do something different. I wanna do something fresh’.” And he succeeded. “Cloud Nine” blasted into the R&B chart in November 1968, eventually spending three weeks at #2 — it was held at bay, ironically, by another Whitfield/Strong composition, Marvin Gaye’s “I Heard It Through The Grapevine.”

Of the two, “Grapevine” was subsequently adjudged one of the greatest records ever made. “Cloud Nine” was simply one of the most important. As George remarked in his history of Motown, “Where Did Our Love Go,” “Isaac Hayes, Barry White, Curtis Mayfield … Gamble and Huff, men who became the cutting edge of black music in the early 1970s, all owed a debt to ‘Cloud Nine’ for opening up black music and preparing the black audience for more progressive directions.”

Neither would the innovation end there. The accompanying album of the same name followed the title track first with a new, supremely funky rendition of “Grapevine,” its signature riff subverted to the ghost of a piano fighting to be heard through the drums. Then with “Run Away Child, Running Wild,” a sprawling nine-minute soundscape which added spacey organ and heartbroken “I want my momma” wailing to the mix — and still emerged a mere shadow of what the same team would create the following year.

1970’s Psychedelic Shack caught The Temptations not only tracing the title track’s convulsive funkadelia, but followed through with the eight-plus minute “Take A Stroll Thru Your Mind,” possibly the most adventurous (and certainly the most experimental) cut ever to grace a Hitsville release. A crazy-paving acid trip, “Take A Trip” was the culmination of a Whitfield vision which returning bassist Jamerson summed up, so succinctly, as “monstrous funk.”

Familiar refrains and beats raced past like highway signs, and ghostly guitars scythed through the walking bass. the history of Motown itself was drenched in a lysergic dreamscape which alternately lulled and lured the listener, before the entire thing climaxed with one monstrous gong blast, as shattering to the senses as the firearm blast which opened “Shotgun” five years earlier. 

Neither were The Temptations to be the sole beneficiaries of Whitfield’s inventiveness. Throughout 1970-71, Rare Earth (the first white rock act to be signed to Motown, albeit for the shortlived Rare Earth subsidiary) and Edwin Starr were both propelled to glory on the back of Whitfield’s funk-caked streams of socio-political consciousness, with Starr’s “War” — reprised from Psychedelic Shack to become a pop #1 during fall 1970 — swiftly ascending to the stature of social anthem. 

Starr’s Christmas-time follow-up, “Stop The War Now,” was even more outspoken, while the new year’s “Funky Music Sho’ Nuff Turns Me On” (backed by a dangerous new interpretation of “Cloud 9”) evidenced just how strongly the winds of change had blown through Motown. Once, Gordy wouldn’t even allow the word “funk” on the sleeve of an album which, in all fairness to the Brothers, was highly unlikely to bother the chart. Now it was emblazoned across a follow-up to one of Motown’s biggest hits of the past 12 months.

If Whitfield and (suddenly, less significantly) the Clan were the spearhead which drove Motown into the new decade, they were not alone. Funk Brother Earl Van Dyke released a solo album, The Earl Of Funk, in September 1970, a set of lunging lounge-piano recreations of the day’s biggest hits, complete with stylized renditions of Sly Stone’s bass splurge “Thank You Falettin Me Be Mice Elf Again” and The Meters’ “Cissy Strut,” while Jobete staff writer Al Cleveland and the Four Tops’  Renaldo Benson took advantage of the new climate to present Marvin Gaye with “What’s Going On,” a reflective and apparently all-encompassing contemplation of the state of the nation.

It was a powerful song and, in its implications, a frightening one. Gaye himself resisted recording it for several weeks before throwing himself into first the song itself, and then an entire album in a similar vein.  

Now it was Motown’s turn to draw the line. With Gordy allegedly pronouncing What’s Going On the worst record he’d ever heard, Gaye’s album sat on the shelf for close to six months, even after “What’s Going On” itself, reluctantly released as a single, topped the R&B chart. It was June 1971 before Motown saw fit to release the parent album, their reluctance to commit either artist or label to this radical new direction so strong that it even broke another of the company’s most ironclad traditions of always having a fresh smash ready the moment the last one began slipping down the chart. 

Of course, once What’s Going On proved its commercial worth, there was to be no holding back. Two further singles, “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)” and “Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler),” topped the chart, making 1971 Gaye’s most successful year in such terms since 1968 and “Grapevine.” What’s Going On topped the R&B chart for nine weeks while, across the spectrum, music critics flocked to heap fresh and further accolades upon it. 

In 1985, Nelson George described What’s Going On as “a recording on par” with Sly Stones’ Stand and the Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band. Ten years later, Mojo magazine adjudged it #6 in a wide-ranging poll of the 100 Greatest Albums Ever Made. (Stand came in at #65, Pepper at #51.)

Even more important, however, was the opinion of Gaye’s own peers. It is no coincidence whatsoever that What’s Going On should be followed, almost immediately, with commentary as hard-hitting as Funkadelic’s America Eats Its Young, Sly & the Family Stone’s There’s A Riot Goin’ On and Isaac Hayes’ Shaft. Indeed, Hayes himself acknowledged that his soundtrack was inescapably informed by “ … what happened in the ’60s, the civil rights struggle, the Vietnam issues and so forth.”

All three were cut in the shadow of What’s Going On, and all three brought to the mass marketplace a black consciousness which had hitherto been buried away either in the polemic of one-off 45s (“War,” the Temptations’ “Ball Of Confusion”), or else consigned to the obscurity of underground cult acts.

Certainly Stevie Wonder understood the implications of Gaye’s new stance, instantly combining the despite-it-all success of What’s Going On with his own plans for artistic independence. Wonder’s 21st birthday on May 13, 1971 also marked the expiration of his existing contract with Motown. Of course he renewed it, but only after leaving the company on tenterhooks through weeks of renegotiation, and only after informing them that he now intended to explore his own creativity as thoroughly as he and his advisers had explored their options before signing the deal.

He proved true to his word. Absolutely inspired within the recently (September, 1970) deceased Jimi Hendrix’s Electric Lady Studios in New York, a year’s worth of sessions saw Wonder complete the heart of all four albums — Music Of My Mind and Talking Book, both 1972; Innervisions, 1973; and Fulfillingness’ First Finale, 1974.

Each kept pace with developments not only elsewhere within the worlds of soul, funk and R&B, but in the heart of rock territory, too. During this same period, Wonder guested on recordings by Peter Frampton, Dave Mason and James Taylor. He toured with The Rolling Stones and wrote songs for Jeff Beck. It was a ferocious burst of creativity which only let up when Wonder was involved and almost killed in a highway accident in 1973.

By the time he returned to action in 1976 with the Songs In The Key Of Life double album, Wonder was one of the biggest stars in the world — his new album being one of the most eagerly anticipated in history. And his record label, home now to acts as far apart as The Commodores and The Undisputed Truth, Jerry Butler and the Dynamic Superiors, actor Albert Finney and diva Thelma Houston, was now home to some of the most esoteric and adventurous sounds around. It was, indeed, all a very long way from the Motown of old.

Related Posts:

Posted in ArticlesComments (0)

The last Supremes


 By Peter Lindblad
The Supremes lineup for 'High Energy' included Scherrie Payne, Susaye Greene and Mary Wilson. (Motown)
The Supremes lineup for ‘High Energy’ included Scherrie Payne, Susaye Greene and Mary Wilson. (Motown)
Nine ladies, in all, would wind up being Supremes. And while everybody knows of Diana Ross and Mary Wilson, many others contributed to a story that has to go down as one of the most fascinating and glamorous in all of pop-music history.

Three of those women, Lynda Laurence, Scherrie Payne and Susaye Green, were in the group when Motown had, for all intents and purposes, turned their back on The Supremes. Their stories add to the rich history of a group that was nothing less than absolute royalty.

Lynda Laurence, 1972-1973

The Supremes had an opening in 1972, due to Cindy Birdsong’s pregnancy, but Lynda Laurence wasn’t interested … at first.

“I was very content singing backup with Stevie [Wonder, as a member of Wonderlove], because that was like going to school. He’s such a musical genius,” explains Laurence.

Part of her education involved singing backing vocals on Wonder’s smash 1970 hit “Signed, Sealed, Delivered I’m Yours.” She is easily heard above the song’s exuberant din.

“All those little yells and screams in the background, that’s me,” says Laurence. “And everybody thought that was Stevie. And so, when we went on the road, he would tell everybody, ‘That’s her. That’s not me (laughs).’”

Finding her work with Wonder incredibly rewarding, Laurence had no desire to leave Wonderlove. And when a pregnant Cindy Birdsong was about to leave The Supremes in 1972 to start a family with husband Charles Hewlett, she had no inkling she would eventually join perhaps the greatest girl group ever.

Early on, it became apparent the search for the next Supreme would home in on the girls of Wonderlove. Not only was Laurence was one of them, but so was her sister Sundray Tucker. Laurence figured Sundray was a lock to get the job.

“When Cindy left, she asked for my sister to audition, because they saw us working together in Washington at the Carter Barron Amphitheatre with Stevie,” says Laurence. “Well, [Cindy] and my sister looked more like sisters than she and I, than my sister and I. Everybody said that all of our lives. So my thing is, I’m telling everybody, ‘My sister’s going to be one of the Supremes! My sister’s going to be one of the Supremes!’ And I was so excited. I just knew that was going to happen.”

Even beyond the physical similarities, there was ample evidence to support Laurence’s conclusion, considering how far back the connection between Birdsong and Sundray went.

Originally, Birdsong was from Delaware, and Laurence and her sister called Philadelphia home. It was Birdsong who actually replaced Sundray in The Ordettes, the precursor to Patti LaBelle & The Bluebelles.

“My sister was actually singing with a group that they were all in prior to them taking over [as] the Bluebelles,” says Laurence. “They were all in a group together that my father [Ira Tucker, the gospel songwriter, producer and lead singer of The Dixie Hummingbirds] used to rehearse in our living room in Philadelphia, and this consisted of Patti and Cindy and a couple other girls.”

Birdsong, in 1967, surprised The Bluebelles by agreeing to join The Supremes, taking the spot of Florence Ballard. Birdsong’s departure soured relations between her and LaBelle for years.

At this time, however, Sundray was with The Three Degrees, but her stay with them was brief, and when Birdsong moved on to The Supremes, Sundray returned to The Bluebelles.

When time came for Birdsong to leave The Supremes, Sundray was summoned to try out. But it wasn’t meant to be.  

“When the auditions finished, they said they wanted to see the other sister, and that was me,” relates Laurence. “When they called me to do the audition, I wasn’t going to go, because my thought was, ‘If I don’t go, they’ll probably choose her.’”

It wasn’t that simple, as Laurence would find out, “ … because I spoke with, at the time, Charlie Atkins, who was one of my biggest mentors in the business, said to me that even though I may not take this position, it is not in stone that they’re going to hire my sister,” says Laurence. “So I said, ‘Oh no. What should I do?’ He said, ‘You should audition.’”

Needless to say, Laurence was in a tough spot. So she went to see the one person whose opinion she valued perhaps above all others: Stevie Wonder.

“So I went to Steve — we all called him Steve — and I said, ‘What should I do?’ I said, ‘Listen, I don’t wanna do this.’ And he said, ‘Are you sure they’re going to hire your sister?’ And I said, ‘No.’ And he said, ‘Well, I’ll tell you what. With me, you’ll be a backup singer. But if you get the job with The Supremes, you’ll be one of The Supremes,’” says Laurence. “And he said, ‘I think that’s something worth trying for.’ I said, ‘OK.’ And so, because of Stevie Wonder, I’m in the group.” 

Laurence didn’t remain with The Supremes for very long. Her tenure lasted just one year. Still, it was a dream come true for Laurence, who idolized The Supremes when she was young.

“Who didn’t?” she asked. “I mean, I went to see them when they were at the Uptown Theater in Philadelphia. And oh my goodness, I remember sitting there, and they were singing ‘Buttered Popcorn’ and ‘Where Did Our Love Go?’ And oh, I was excited. I said, ‘Wow! Look at that.’ This is before the mega gowns, and before they actually came into their own, so to speak. But they still had on matching dresses and they were pretty and they sounded great. I just loved it.”

Once she was in, however, Laurence had work to do. She, Jean Terrell and Mary Wilson rehearsed diligently — on choreography and songs — for two and a half months to prepare for Laurence’s first show, “ … because The Supremes’ book was massive. We did show tunes … you know, we did everything.”

Laurence wanted to make sure she left no stone unturned. “I wanted to learn the whole book,” she said. “I didn’t want to learn just the basic show they were doing. I wanted to learn the whole book so that if someone called for something, I would know it.”

An admirable goal, but Laurence wasn’t prepared for what fate had in store.

“Two weeks before we were to open [at the H.I.C. Arena in Hawaii] … Mary was extremely concerned because Jean Terrell had become ill and she wasn’t able to do it, and we had two weeks before the job,” says Laurence. “So it was too late to cancel. So I said to Mary, ‘Well, can you do it?’ And she said, ‘No. You’re going to have to do it.’ I said, ‘Do what?’ And she said, ‘You’re going to have to be the lead singer.’ I said, ‘No.’ (laughs).”

Wilson wouldn’t take “no” for an answer, and she expressed her faith in Laurence’s abilities to the new Supreme. So Laurence changed her focus and set about learning all of the lead vocals.

“The first thing I remember is someone saying, ‘Ladies and gentlemen, The Supremes,’” says Laurence. “The next thing I remember is Cindy saying to me, ‘Oh, that was fantastic! You did a great job. You were great,’ hugging me and lights going off, and the dressing room and flashes … I was standing there going, ‘What happened?’ I was in fear. I’m not kidding. It’s as if I blanked.”

Laurence may never recapture those memories. “I went to the doctor, and she said, outside of someone hypnotising me, I would not be able to know. And so, to this day, I’ve seen photos, I’ve heard what I sang, and I was like, ‘I can’t believe I did that.’”

Laurence’s tenure in The Supremes wouldn’t last long. She stayed about a year. Though she appeared on the cover of the 1972 album Floy Joy, it was Birdsong who sang on the record. However, Laurence did record a Stevie Wonder-produced single “Bad Weather” with the group, plus the LP The Supremes Produced And Arranged By Jimmy Webb and the concert record Live In Japan.

Leaving The Supremes was somewhat difficult for Laurence, “ … but it was a necessary thing. Things had gone a little south with Motown at that time, and The Supremes weren’t getting any — in my estimation — of the support they needed at the time. So it was a decision that I felt I needed to make. And it wasn’t an easy one, because I knew if I had stayed, I would have been lead singer.”

And wouldn’t you know it? Her replacement was none other than Cindy Birdsong.

Scherrie Payne, 1973-1977

The same year that Lynda Laurence exited The Supremes, Jean Terrell followed suit.

Motown’s waning interest in promoting the group had finally gotten the best of her. But her departure created an opening for Scherrie Payne.

Her boyfriend, Lamont Dozier, of the Holland-Dozier-Holland writing and production team behind many Motown hits, helped Payne land the job.

At a party, Mary Wilson, according to Payne, told Dozier that Terrell was leaving and that they were looking for a new lead singer. Tiny of stature, standing just 5’2″, Payne was blessed with a powerful voice, and after she sent Wilson some of her recordings and photos, “ … two days later, I was on a flight to California and that was it.”

But before all that, a much younger Payne had aspirations of being a Supreme, as many young girls did.

“Of course, being from Detroit, I watched them develop,” says Payne. “I loved The Supremes. I was very proud of them. They were very classy. That’s what I loved.”

When Diana Ross left The Supremes in 1970, there was someone else, besides Dozier, who thought Payne could fill her dazzling shoes: Payne’s own mother.

“I remember when Diana was leaving, my mother urged me to present myself, and I said, ‘Oh, no, no, no. I couldn’t … Are you kidding? No, I couldn’t do that,’” remembers Payne. “We were at a banquet, I think, and she was sitting next to Esther Edwards, Berry’s [Gordy] sister, and of course, she had grown up with him in the same church, and they were talking and she started to tell Esther about me. And I was nudging her, like, ‘Shut up (laughs). Are you kidding? Don’t put me on the spot like that.’ So I was furious with her.”

Three years later though, the so-called “little lady with the big voice” did wind up with The Supremes, joining original member Mary Wilson and longtime Supremes veteran Cindy Birdsong.

Before getting called up to the Majors, so to speak, Payne was lead singer for Glass House. The group was on the Invictus Label, formed by Dozier and Eddie and Brian Holland following their exit from Motown. The label had a #1 hit with The Honey Cone’s “Want Ads,” which, coincidentally, was originally recorded by Glass House and featured Payne on lead vocals. 

Glass House, who released two albums and nine singles between 1969 and 1972, did reach the Billboard Top 10 in 1969 with their biggest hit “Crumbs Off The Table,” featuring lead vocals by Payne. Whatever success they experienced, however, was dwarfed by The Supremes’ chart domination. So when it came time for Payne to go with The Supremes, understandably, she had cold feet.

“Oh, it was a tremendous difference. The Supremes were worldwide. Glass House was more or less a local group,” says Payne. “I mean, it was a giant leap for me. Not to try to put my other comrades down … it was overwhelming. It really was. It was an overwhelming step. In fact, I panicked after I told Mary I was getting on the plane.

It was Payne’s mother who came to the rescue with a pep talk that convinced her she could, indeed, fit right in. And she did, immediately.

It was a whirlwind courtship for Payne.

“Right from the airport, Cindy Birdsong picked me up,” recalls Payne. “She had just returned to The Supremes herself, and we went straight to Mary’s house, suitcases and all. And we went right into rehearsal. That was on a Saturday, because we had a gig the following Friday or the following Saturday. I think it was in New Mexico at the state fair.”

Thrown right into the fire, those first rehearsals didn’t go smoothly for Payne. Payne had to memorize a lot in a short amount of time, “ … steps, lyrics — mainly lyrics, because I didn’t have to do as many steps as Mary and Cindy, because I was doing a lot of the leads.”

Mary told her, though, “ … if you can get through this, you’ve got the job.”

That first show, before a large audience, was a blur, says Payne. “It just went by so fast.” Despite everything, Payne pulled it off with aplomb. Backstage afterward, she found out she was hired.

 And with the strong support of Wilson and Birdsong’s own vocals, Payne stepped out front and delivered, bringing to The Supremes a big, bold singing style infused with plenty of attitude. And that strength, that undeniable show of force she displayed, helped The Supremes transition to disco on The Supremes ’75.

The successor to 1972’s The Supremes Produced And Arranged By Jimmy Webb, The Supremes ’75 was a long time in coming for the newly configured group. Contract problems and the personnel shuffling had delayed new Supremes material. It wasn’t until August 1974 that they began recording, and Payne took center stage on “He’s My Man,” the first single and a #1 hit on the Billboard disco charts.

“Gregory Wright had written that song and Mary and I shared lead on that,” says Payne. “It’s a nice dance song, a good dance song.”

As for The Supremes ’75, Payne has only fond memories of the recording process.

Still, Payne, who was an accomplished songwriter before coming to The Supremes, does have one regret: She wishes she had written more material for the group. “I sort of put it to the side,” admits Payne, “and I shouldn’t have.”

Though she did help usher The Supremes into the disco age, Payne felt let down that Motown had, in essence, abandoned the group during her tenure. 

Things could have been different. When asked if The Supremes could have recaptured their former glory if Motown had paid them more attention, Payne replied, “Absolutely. We could have done so much more, because we had the talent, the writers — everything was in place.”

When the end came in 1977, with a farewell concert in London, Payne, who would later write the song “One Night Only” for the play and movie “Dreamgirls,” based on The Supremes’ story, says, “I was devastated. I imagine I felt like Mary did when she found out Diana was going to leave.”

Susaye Greene, 1976-1977

The last to join, Susaye Greene, like Lynda Laurence, was with Wonderlove when she was approached about becoming a Supreme.

And while Stevie Wonder, who was working on his Songs In The Key Of Life LP at the time, gave his blessing to Laurence when she changed allegiances, Green’s imminent departure was greeted with less enthusiasm.

“Well, Stevie was very upset with me about leaving the group, because I had carte blanche, so to speak,” explains Greene. “I selected the material that I sang. I performed what I wanted to on his show. I had solo spots in his show, and … it was a wonderful musical growth situation.”

But being in Wonderlove wasn’t the same as being one of The Supremes. And like Scherrie Payne, who would partner with Greene to record the underrated LP Partners after The Supremes were permanently put on ice in 1977, Greene had a little help from her mom.

Her mother was on the board of the Beverly Hills branch of the NAACP with Bob Jones, the head of publicity at Motown. Jones revealed to Greene’s mother that Birdsong was to leave the group and wanted to know if Susaye wanted to replace her.

When Greene was asked, “I said, ‘Well, it sounds intriguing. That’s something I’ve never done (laughs),’” says Greene.

At the time, The Supremes were out on the road. Greene met with Mary Wilson’s husband and manager, Pedro Ferrer, and they talked. Ferrer said they wanted someone who could sing lead. “He wanted everyone [in The Supremes] to be able to sing lead. And they were trying to regain — how shall we put it — within [Motown]  a higher attention.”

 Ferrer had done his homework on Greene, whose resumé was extensive. In addition to Wonderlove, Greene was a Raelette, the girl group that performed backing vocals for Ray Charles. In fact, Greene first encountered Mary Wilson and The Supremes while with The Raelettes.

“We had met when I was with Ray at the Carter Barron (Amphitheatre) in Washington, D.C.,” says Greene. “I believe Jean Terrell had been in the group a very short time, and they opened for Ray Charles. So all of us, the Raelettes, were stuck to the side of the stage trying to see what was going on. This was The Supremes after all … they had all the wigs and the hair, the full regalia, the sparkles and delights — the fantasy of The Supremes — and they were marvelous.”

Later, backstage, Greene remembers “ … talking with Ray and we were in there laughing and chuckling,’ when Wilson and Charles were sorting out who would get to use a reception area in Charles’ dressing room.

“When I went to meet her for The Supremes, she said (Greene’s voice excited), ‘Oh, you’re that little girl (laughs) who was there with Ray,’” relates Greene.

It could have been an awkward introduction, but Payne and Wilson welcomed her with open arms. “Oh, I’m sure there were some misgivings,” says Greene. “I’m sure they were disappointed that Cindy was leaving, but they showed none of that to me, because they are such lovely, gracious, professional ladies.”

As an aside, Greene was with Wilson in 1976 when she received the news that former Supreme Florence Ballard, her tragic story recounted many times over, had died.

“Oh, it was just heartbreaking,” says Greene. “Mary is a very emotional lady, very tender. And I could see she was just brokenhearted, because it represented the end of her dream in a way.”

 In a sense, Greene’s arrival signaled a new beginning for The Supremes. Ferrer knew Greene had talent beyond her singing. After all, she had written the song “Free” that Deniece Williams took straight up to #1 in the U.K., and she had — and still does — written with Stevie Wonder (later, she would compose “I Can’t Help It” for Michael Jackson, a song that wound up on Off The Wall).

So, in negotiating Greene’s membership in The Supremes, promises were made. “I was told I would be able to write and possibly produce things for the group,” says Greene.

There were other benefits. Greene recalls that Wilson would often pick her up in a long, white Mercedes limousine, with black windows, that was once owned by George Harrison, and they would go shopping to get Greene ready to go on the road.

“We had a lot of appointments, trying on clothes, you know, a lot of beaded gowns … oh, what a fantasy for a lady that is (laughs),” says Greene.

A size 3 at the time “ … or something ridiculous (laughs),” adds Greene, “I was just a slip of a girl.” So she wore Diana’s gowns. “And this gown, I swear to you, weighed 35 pounds, and the bottom was weighted, so that once you put it on and it would fit, it kind of had a life of its own.”

As Greene says, it was ideal for doing “the dip-and-swoop, which was a Supremes thing.” And she would first do “Supremes things” as part of the group on an episode of the TV show “Soul Train.”

“I remember not knowing any of the choreography,” says Greene. “And that made me feel a bit insecure, so you just kind of keep smiling and (laughs) moving those arms around and singing those songs, singing the words.”

Unfortunately, Greene, blessed with a voice that could range over multiple octaves, didn’t get to fully display all of her prodigious talent with The Supremes. She did appear, however, on the last two Supremes albums, including 1976’s High Energy. Greene remembers the recording of that LP being a “nerve-wracking experience, because it was all new to me, that particular style of recording. First of all, we did very little recording at the same time. We did a whole lot of piece work where the tracks were done. You weren’t involved in that part and that was killing me.”

She compliments the Holland brothers for pulling together a cohesive album, but for Greene, who had experience producing and was able to notice things in the studio that could be improved upon, recording High Energy was a frustrating experience, especially in light of the latitude she was given while working with Stevie Wonder.

“Basically, you show up, look cute and hit the spot,” says Greene.

To her dissatisfaction, Greene was never allowed to write or produce for The Supremes. Still, she harbors no bitterness about her days with The Supremes.

Related Posts:

Posted in ArticlesComments (0)

EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Sign up to receive Goldmine's free weekly eNewsletter and get weekly updates on your favorite classic artists and the music collecting hobby!
Email:

FOLLOW US

Twitter Facebook Myspace YouTube

A LOOK INSIDE: The Spin Clean Record Washing System

Polls

Which Rolling Stones album is the biggest disappointment in the band's 50-year career?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

SPONSORS